Friday, October 17, 2008

What students should be in a WhyTry group together?

One of the questions I am often asked is what type of students should be included in a WhyTry group. Another version of this questions is, "Should I have all of the 'At-Risk' students together in one group?" According to Irvin Yalom, a leading expert in group therapy and process, this is one of the most difficult and confusing areas in the group therapy literature. Furthermore, in a school setting, we are often constrained by time, the needs of the students, the availability of space and students, and many other variables.
I want to address this question from an article recently written by Kenneth Dodge and published in American Psychologist: Journal of the American Psychological Association. Dr. Dodge investigates the deviant peer influence. He found from a review of the literature that comprising prevention/intervention groups with with a "all deviant peer-group" were 1/3 less effective than working with these young people individually. However, not all youths are influenced by deviant peers. There is no evidence to show that nondeviant youths initiate deviant behavior when exposed to individuals who are currently engaging in deviant behavior. In fact, it is often seen that in this setting the deviant youth will more likely conform to the norms established by the nondeviant youths as long as the culture in the classroom remains prosocial and positive. In conclusion, when comprising groups, deviant youths should not be placed with peers with similar behavior profiles. For example, drug users should not be matched with other drug users. The groups should be a mixture of all youth where everyone can learn from each other. We are each teachers to one another. Every person has value and worth and something wonderful to share and teach us for living in this world together.
Below is the reference to this article. It is an excellent article and provides tons of information on prevention research and violence prevention in youth. I highly recommend reading it. Thank you for your devotion and dedication to bringing light and love to the lives of others!

Dodge, K. (2008). Framing public policy and prevention of chronic violence in American youths. American Psychologist, 63(7), 573 - 590.

No comments: